You have decided to replace a missing tooth with a dental implant. Then the next question shows up: who should actually place it? Your regular dentist, an oral surgeon, and a periodontist can all do it, and each one will tell you something slightly different about why they are the right choice.
The honest answer is that all three can place implants well. What changes from case to case is how complex your mouth is, who plans the treatment, and who makes the final tooth. This guide explains what each type of provider does, how they are trained, and how to match the provider to your case.
Short answer: a general dentist with implant training is often a good fit for a single tooth with healthy bone and gums. An oral surgeon is a common choice for complex surgery, such as major bone loss or several extractions with implants in the same visit. A periodontist is a common choice when gum disease or gum and bone health is the main concern. In every case, the experience of the person placing your implant matters more than the title.
The Three Providers at a Glance
| General dentist | Oral and maxillofacial surgeon | Periodontist | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Training | Dental degree (DDS or DMD), plus implant courses and mentored cases | Dental degree, then a hospital-based surgical residency (typically four to six years) | Dental degree, then a residency in gum disease and implants (typically three years) |
| Focus | Whole-mouth care | Surgery of the mouth, jaws, and face | Gums, supporting bone, and implants |
| Typical implant role | Plans, places, and restores | Places the implant, often with grafting or extractions | Places the implant, often with gum or bone work |
| Who makes the final tooth | Usually the same dentist | Usually your general dentist | Usually your general dentist |
| Best known for | Convenience and one office | Complex surgical cases | Gum and bone health |
Training varies between individual providers, and some general dentists have far more implant experience than the table suggests. Treat it as a starting point, then ask about the specific person who will treat you.
What a General Dentist Does
A general dentist holds a DDS or DMD degree and treats the whole mouth: checkups, fillings, crowns, gum care, and extractions. Many general dentists add implant training through continuing education courses and mentored cases, and they place and restore implants as part of everyday care.
Dental school takes four years. Implant training after that comes from continuing education courses, mentored cases, and, for some dentists, longer programs focused on implants. Because the same dentist can place the implant and make the crown, one person often follows your case from the first scan through your regular checkups. A careful general dentist also knows when a case is beyond their experience and says so. A referral for a complex case is a sign of good judgment, not a weakness.
Where this works well
- A single missing tooth with healthy bone and gums
- Several teeth that need an implant-supported bridge
- Patients who want one team and one office from scan to final crown
What to ask: how many implants the dentist has placed, what training they have completed, and whether they use 3D imaging and guided surgery.
What an Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon Does
An oral and maxillofacial surgeon is a dental specialist who completes a hospital-based surgical residency after dental school. These surgeons treat conditions of the mouth, jaws, and face. That includes difficult extractions, bone grafts, sinus lifts, jaw surgery, and facial trauma, along with implant placement.
The residency typically lasts four to six years in a hospital setting and includes extensive anesthesia training. That is why surgeons can offer everything from local anesthesia to general anesthesia for longer or more complex surgery. Some cases also need work done before the implant, such as removing impacted teeth or correcting jaw alignment, and that falls within an oral surgeon’s training.
Where this works well
- Significant bone loss that needs a graft before or during placement
- Several extractions with implants planned in the same visit
- Complex anatomy, such as an implant near the sinus or a nerve
- Patients who want IV sedation or general anesthesia for a longer surgery
What to know: in many surgical practices, the surgeon places the implant and your general dentist makes the final crown. That works well when the two offices communicate, but it means two offices, two schedules, and often two bills.
What a Periodontist Does
A periodontist is a dental specialist in gum disease and the structures that support your teeth. After dental school, periodontists complete a residency focused on gums, bone, and dental implants. They treat gum disease, perform gum and bone grafts, and place implants.
The residency usually lasts three years and centers on gum grafting, bone grafting, and implants. Healthy, well-shaped gum tissue protects the implant from bacteria and decides how natural the crown looks. That matters most for front teeth, where thin or receding gums can expose the implant post. Periodontists also provide long-term gum care around implants and treat peri-implantitis, the gum and bone inflammation that can affect an implant years later.
Where this works well
- A history of gum disease or bone loss around your teeth
- Thin or receding gums where the soft tissue needs reshaping
- Treating an infection around an existing implant
- Cases where gum health will decide whether the implant lasts
What to know: like surgeons, periodontists often place the implant and send you back to your general dentist for the crown.
What About a Prosthodontist?
A prosthodontist is a dental specialist in replacing teeth and rebuilding bites. Prosthodontists often plan complex cases, design the final teeth, and in some practices place the implants too. They are a common choice for full-arch cases and for patients who need several teeth rebuilt together.
Prosthodontists complete a three-year residency after dental school that focuses on rebuilding teeth and bites. Their strength is designing the final result: tooth shape, bite alignment, and materials. Many work alongside a surgeon or periodontist who places the implants, and some place them as well.
Is an “Implantologist” a Specialist?
You may see providers described as an implantologist or a dental implant specialist. Neither title is a dental specialty recognized by the American Dental Association. Any licensed dentist can use those words, so they say little about training on their own. Ask what courses the dentist has completed, how long they have placed implants, and how many cases like yours they have treated.
Placing the Implant vs. Restoring It
A dental implant has two phases, and different providers may handle each one.
- Surgical phase. The implant post is placed in the jawbone, and any grafting or extractions are done.
- Restorative phase. After healing, the abutment and the final crown, bridge, or denture are made and attached.
There are two ways to organize that work.
| One office handles both phases | Surgeon or periodontist places, your dentist restores | |
|---|---|---|
| Planning | One team plans the whole case | Two offices share the plan |
| Scheduling | One set of appointments | Visits split between offices |
| Billing | One treatment plan and fee review | Often two separate bills |
| Communication | Inside one office | Depends on how well the two offices share records |
| Best for | Straightforward and moderate cases | Complex surgical cases |
Neither model is better in every case. A well-coordinated team model can work very well for a complex case. What matters is that someone owns the whole plan, so the implant is placed where the final tooth needs it to be.
When Specialists Work Together
Many complex cases are treated by more than one provider, and that is normal. A common pattern looks like this:
- A periodontist treats gum disease and prepares the gum tissue.
- An oral surgeon removes teeth and rebuilds bone where needed, then places the implants.
- Your general dentist or a prosthodontist makes the final teeth and handles checkups afterward.
The handoffs decide how smooth this feels. To keep a team approach on track, ask for these:
- One shared 3D scan and one written treatment plan
- Input from the dentist who will make the crown before surgery, because implants work best when the planned final tooth decides where the implant goes
- A clear statement of who handles each visit and each fee
- Records sent between offices before each stage
Bone Grafts and Sinus Lifts: Who Does Them?
Many implant patients need more bone before placement. Years without a tooth, gum disease, or an infection can thin the jawbone, and an implant needs enough bone to hold it in place. Common procedures include:
- Socket preservation. A graft placed at an extraction site to keep the bone from shrinking while it heals.
- Ridge augmentation. A graft that rebuilds the width or height of the jawbone.
- Sinus lift. A procedure that adds bone beneath the sinus in the upper back jaw, where a missing tooth often leaves little bone.
Oral surgeons and periodontists both perform these procedures, and some general dentists with advanced training do as well. Grafting adds healing time, often several months before the implant goes in, although in some cases the graft and the implant can be placed in the same visit. Ask who will do the graft, what material will be used, and how the plan changes if healing takes longer.
Which Provider Fits Your Case?
| Your situation | Often a good fit |
|---|---|
| One missing tooth, healthy bone and gums | General dentist with implant training |
| Several missing teeth in a row | General dentist or prosthodontist |
| Full-arch replacement | General dentist with full-arch experience, prosthodontist, or surgeon |
| Significant bone loss or a sinus lift | Oral surgeon or periodontist |
| Gum disease history | Periodontist, or a dentist who treats the gums before placement |
| Several extractions plus implants | Oral surgeon, or a dentist with surgical training |
| Dental anxiety | Any provider that offers the sedation level you want |
| Problem with an existing implant | Periodontist, surgeon, or a dentist experienced in implant repair |
This table describes common patterns, not rules. A skilled general dentist can handle many cases that fall in the “surgeon” rows, and a surgeon can handle simple cases. Your 3D scan and exam decide the plan.
Common Situations, Explained
One missing back tooth, healthy gums, and plenty of bone. This is the most straightforward case. An experienced general dentist can plan, place, and restore it, and one office can handle every visit.
A tooth that needs to come out because of infection. The tooth is removed, and the site may need a bone graft to keep the ridge intact. Depending on the infection and the bone, the implant may go in at the same visit or after several months of healing. Dentists, surgeons, and periodontists all treat this situation, and the 3D scan decides the timing.
Gum disease with loose teeth. Gum disease has to be treated before implants go in, because infected gums put the implant at risk. A periodontist, or a dentist who treats gum disease, usually starts the plan, and the implant phase comes after the gums are stable.
An upper back tooth with little bone under the sinus. A sinus lift may be needed first. A surgeon or periodontist is a common choice, and your 3D scan shows how much bone is there.
Years of wearing dentures and wanting fixed teeth. Full-arch treatment depends on bone quality and the number of implants, and it requires careful planning of the final teeth. Look for a team with full-arch experience, whatever their title.
Questions to Ask Before You Choose Implant Dentist
Whoever you meet, ask:
- Who will place my implant, and who will make the crown?
- What training do you have in implant dentistry?
- How many implants like mine have you placed?
- Will I have a 3D scan, and will you show it to me?
- Do you use a surgical guide?
- What sedation options do you offer?
- What does the full quote include? Ask for the implant, abutment, crown, imaging, grafting, sedation, and follow-up visits in writing.
- What happens if something goes wrong after surgery?
A good provider answers these directly and does not rush you.
What Matters More Than the Title
Two providers with the same title can deliver very different care. These details tell you more than a job title:
- 3D imaging before surgery. A 3D (CBCT) scan shows bone thickness, nerve position, and sinus space. A flat X-ray cannot.
- A written plan. You should see the plan, the steps, and the fees before treatment starts.
- Guided surgery. A surgical guide helps place each implant at the planned angle and depth.
- Experience with your type of case. Ask for specifics, not general reassurance.
- Honest talk about risks. Infection, an implant that does not fuse with the bone, and nerve or sinus issues are rare but real. A good provider explains how they reduce them.
Sedation Dentistry and Anesthesia Options
Fear of the procedure keeps many people from replacing a missing tooth, so ask about comfort early. Most implant placement uses local anesthesia, which numbs the area so you feel pressure but not pain. Dental Sedation adds relaxation on top of it:
- Nitrous oxide. A light gas that takes the edge off. It wears off quickly.
- Oral sedation. A prescribed pill taken before the visit.
- IV sedation. Medication given through a vein for deeper relaxation.
- General anesthesia. Deep sleep, usually reserved for longer or more complex surgery and offered mainly by surgical specialists in a properly equipped office.
Options differ by practice, so ask which levels are available, who monitors you during the procedure, and whether it costs extra. Plan for a ride home after any sedation beyond local anesthesia. At Clearwater Dental Associates, we offer light IV sedation for patients who prefer it.
After Surgery: Follow-Up and Long-Term Care
Placing the implant is one step. Healing checks, the final crown, and long-term maintenance matter just as much, and they are worth asking about before you choose.
- Healing checks. The provider who places the implant usually sees you in the first weeks to check the site. In a split-office model, ask who handles problems that come up at night or on a weekend.
- The final tooth. Once the implant has fused with the bone, the abutment and crown are made and attached.
- Regular care. Brush and floss around the implant daily, and keep your cleanings and exams. Your dentist checks the gums and bite around the implant at each visit.
- Warning signs. Bleeding, swelling, pus, a bad taste, or a loose crown can point to infection or gum inflammation around the implant. Call the office promptly, because early treatment is simpler.
- Heavy biting. If you grind your teeth, ask about a night guard to protect the implant and crown.
How Cost and Billing Differ
Costs depend on your case far more than on the provider’s title, so this guide does not give a price for each type. The split between offices does affect how you pay.
- When two offices share your care, expect two sets of fees: the surgical phase and the restorative phase.
- Insurance may treat each phase differently. Some plans help with extractions, grafts, or the final crown, and some exclude the implant itself.
- Ask each office for an itemized written quote, then compare the totals for the whole treatment, not for one visit.
A few details are worth confirming with each office. Ask whether the surgical quote includes grafting, sedation, and follow-up visits, and whether the restorative quote includes the abutment and a temporary tooth. Ask how claims are filed, since surgical services may be billed differently from restorative ones. A quote that looks lower can leave out parts that another office includes, so compare line by line.
How We Handle Implant Care at Clearwater Dental Associates
At Clearwater Dental Associates, our dentists plan, place, and restore dental implants in one office, so you work with one team from scan to final crown. The team includes Dr. Nolan W. Allen, Dr. Matthew R. Burton, Dr. James R. Hayslett, Dr. Maria C. Hernandez, Dr. Keith M. Kiskaddon, and Dr. William Spencer. Dr. Hernandez speaks English and Spanish.
Every case starts with a Planmeca 3D scan. We take a digital impression and order a surgical guide, and we offer light IV sedation for patients who prefer it. If your case needs a different approach, such as treating gum disease first, we say so at your consultation and explain why.
Because the same team plans the implant and makes the final tooth, we can plan each implant around where the finished tooth needs to sit. The same office also treats gum disease, performs extractions, and handles emergency care, so many steps that could involve a second office stay under one roof. If your scan shows a case that needs a different approach, we explain why and what comes next.
If you are comparing other Clearwater practices, our guide to the top dental implant dentists in Clearwater, FL covers what each one offers. For a full walkthrough of treatment types and the process, read about dental implants in Clearwater, FL.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a general dentist place dental implants?
Yes. General dentists are licensed to place implants, and many have extra training and years of experience. Ask about their courses, their experience, and whether they use 3D imaging and guided surgery.
Is an oral surgeon better than a dentist for implants?
Not always. An oral surgeon is often the better match for complex surgical cases. For a single tooth with healthy bone and gums, an experienced general dentist can get an excellent result. The right choice depends on your case.
Should I see a periodontist or an oral surgeon for implants?
Both are surgical specialists. A periodontist focuses on gums and supporting bone and is a common choice if gum disease is part of your history. An oral surgeon handles a wider range of jaw surgery and is a common choice for major grafting or extractions.
Who makes the crown if a surgeon places my implant?
Usually your general dentist makes and attaches the final crown, bridge, or denture. Ask both offices how they will coordinate, and who handles each fee.
Does it cost more to see a specialist?
It depends on the case and the practice. Compare itemized written quotes for the whole treatment, including the surgical and restorative phases, before you decide.
Is a dental implant specialist the same as a periodontist or oral surgeon?
No. “Dental implant specialist” is not a recognized dental specialty, so any dentist can use the phrase. Periodontics and oral and maxillofacial surgery are recognized specialties, and each requires additional residency training after dental school.
How do I know if my case is complex?
A 3D scan and exam show it. Significant bone loss, a missing tooth next to the sinus, several extractions, and active gum disease all add complexity. Your dentist should explain what the scan shows and why they recommend a particular plan.
Can I get a second opinion on my implant plan?
Yes, and it is a reasonable step for large or complex plans. Bring your 3D scan and written quote to another practice and compare the plans side by side.
Who should place full-arch implants?
Full-arch treatment uses several implants and a full set of fixed teeth, so experience with that exact treatment matters more than the provider’s title. General dentists, prosthodontists, periodontists, and oral surgeons all treat full-arch cases. Ask how many full-arch cases they have completed, who plans and makes the final teeth, and whether one team handles both the surgery and the restoration.
Do I need a referral to see an oral surgeon or periodontist?
Some surgical offices accept patients without one, and some dental insurance plans require a referral for specialist visits. A referral from your dentist also makes it easier to share records and coordinate care. Check with your plan and with the office.
Is dental implant surgery done under general anesthesia?
Usually not. Most implant placement uses local anesthesia, with or without sedation. General anesthesia is typically reserved for longer or more complex surgery and is offered mainly in surgical specialty offices.
What if I need a bone graft before an implant?
Your dentist or surgeon adds bone to the area first, and it usually needs several months to heal before the implant goes in. In some cases, the graft and the implant can be placed together. The 3D scan shows which approach fits.
Can one office do my implant and my crown?
Yes. Some practices, including ours, plan, place, and restore implants in the same office. Others split the surgical and restorative phases between providers. Ask each office how it works.
How do I know if an implant is failing?
Bleeding, swelling, pus, pain when you chew, or a loose crown are warning signs. Call the office that placed or restored the implant promptly.
Ready to Plan Your Dental Implant?
Choosing who places your implant is much easier once you have your own scan and a written plan in front of you. At Clearwater Dental Associates, your first visit gives you both.
What happens at your consultation
- A dentist reviews your medical and dental history and examines your teeth, gums, and bite.
- We take a Planmeca 3D scan that shows your bone, nerve position, and sinus space.
- Your dentist walks you through the scan and explains what it shows, including whether you need gum treatment, a graft, or another step before an implant.
- You receive a clear plan with your options and timeline, and your fees are reviewed with you before any treatment begins.
- Our team discusses your insurance coverage and payment options.
What to bring
Your insurance card, a list of your medications, and any recent X-rays. If another office has already given you an implant plan or quote, bring it, so your dentist can review it with you.
If your case needs a different approach, such as treating gum disease first, we tell you at the visit and explain why.
Office hours: Monday to Thursday 7 am to 5 pm, Friday 8 am to 1 pm. Call (727) 797-8800 or book online.
Book Your Implant Consultation